« Weird, prehistoric birds | Main | Rapper wrapper »

Familiarity and live performance

This is an insignificant puzzle, but an interesting one to me.

For my birthday, A. got us tickets to two upcoming shows at the Iron Horse and the Calvin. They’re artists I’ve come to know fairly well over the last year or so (though Kathleen Edwards’ output is so limited, so far, that it’s not hard to know pretty much everything.) I’ve found that I enjoy concerts better when I know at least a few of the performer’s songs. I can turn off some of the “what’s going on in this song” thinking, and just be aware of the bits that come with a live performance. I can tune in to the performer’s personality a bit more. I knew nearly every song Josh Ritter played, and for me it was what he added to them that really made it a great show. Once or twice, when we’ve gone to shows at the Horse, I’ve borrowed CDs from A. or gone on the ‘net looking for samples so I know what I’m getting in to.

But even though I’m more excited about going to see performers I already know, sometimes I’ve gone in cold. I didn’t know anything about either Rich Price or Sarah Harmer going in to that show, and it was spectacular; I went looking for the CDs afterwards. I didn’t know much about Mark Erelli when he opened for Nanci Griffith, and that was cool but not enough to make me buy his CDs.

Is it just me? Do you prefer to see shows by people whose music you know, or do you like to discover them on stage?

Now Playing: Dead Man from Tarantula by Ride

Comments

The most amazing experiences I’ve had with bands have generally been with bands I was previously unaware of taking me by surprise. I don’t go out of my way to see bands I don’t know anything about any more, so typically this happens when there’s a band I know and like playing the same show as one I’ve never heard of. Probably the most amazing weekend I’ve ever had musically was when my wife and I travelled to Columbus, Ohio, to see a friend’s band play at a weekend-long party thrown by their label. Of course, we knew my friend’s band’s music. And I knew the music of the Ass Ponys, but had never seen them live, and they were incredible. But I was utterly blown away by at least two bands I was previously unaware of that weekend. Moviola did a country rock kind of thing that really grabbed me. And The Handsome Family just had me gobstopped with their modern take on the Appalachian death ballad tradition. Totally floored me. I hadn’t heard of them before that weekend, and I walked away a gibbering fan boy.

I would have to vote for unknown but screened performers - I didn’t know anything about them before but checked their website, reviews, etc. to see if their music was something I would generally like. I have gone to shows by unknown-to-me and unscreened people and wished I had stayed home and put my head in the oven instead. On the other side, I have gone to see people I already was a fan of and had confirmed that this was someone I really liked and was cool but wasn’t blown away by it.

In a middle path, I went to a show by a band I had never heard of but was playing at a convenient venue and time. I checked out some of their music online and liked it and then went to their show and was totally blown away. Similarly, I went to another show not knowing anything about the group but a friend knew one of the performers and I was similarly amazed and impressed.

We’re so lucky to have so many free, open venues here that I rarely have much to lose by going to check someone out - it’s an excuse to go sit out in my lawn chair and drink beer and check people out. It’s great since most of the live shows are of the singer-songwriter variety, which I like best, but I probably miss out on other types of music that I’d like and the real concentrated (what a lame word - I can’t think of a better one, though) sound that comes from an indoor venue. But if I’m going to pay a cover and brave the smoke, I like knowing what I’m getting into, too.

Post a comment